Get a Slice or a Pie at Goodfellas Pizzeria in OTR!

Jul 7, 2015
2 min read

Our family loves pizza! It's one of the few meals, we can all agree on. We definitely have different opinions on our favorites, but, one pizza place that we all wholeheartedly love is Goodfellas Pizzeria in Over-the-Rhine. You can purchase a slice or a whole pie of delicious NY style pizza. I'd recommend getting a whole pie if you're there with 3 or more. If you're heading in for a quick lunch, then get their $6 pizza deal which includes a big slice, a drink, and your choice of either a breadstick or salad or dessert (11 a.m. - 3 p.m.).

You order at the counter then get a number and they will deliver your pizza to your table. Head upstairs to eat. You will find the coolest bar and some big tables that work great with a larger group. Or, you can dine outside on their patio like we did. Another option is order your pizza to go then head over to beautiful Washington Park and enjoy a pizza picnic lunch with your family.

The menu is posted behind the counter. We ordered a 22" pie (1/2 cheese, 1/2 meatball) to feed 5 of us ($22). The slices are HUGE! So, if you have kids, you might want to ask them to cut the slices into smaller sizes. There are also baked subs, calzones, salads, and desserts. Click here for their menu.

You can select a side salad, desserts and more from the cooler in the front. My daughter highly recommends trying a cannoli ($2.75).

Here is the upstairs bar. I thought it was super cool.

Love the wood floors, stools and the large tables upstairs.

Here is one mac daddy pizza pie. The crust, the sauce, and the toppings all meld together perfectly to make one delicious pie! Even though there were five of us (3 adults and 2 kids), we couldn't finish the pie. We brought home two slices to enjoy later.

We hope you'll get a chance to visit Goodfellas Pizzeria too. Across the street is the Macaroon Bar so if you still need a sweet treat, head on over to check them out.

There are two locations in Greater Cincinnati and you can also find them on Facebook.